Categories: General News

Supreme Court Ruling May Lead to Criminalization of Homelessness, Disproportionately Impacting Disabled Individuals

The Supreme Court Just Opened the Door to the Criminalization of Disability

In a significant decision that highlights an alarming turn in the legal approach towards the homeless and those with ongoing disabilities, the Supreme Court recently upheld that individuals experiencing homelessness may be subjected to both criminal and civil penalties for sleeping in public spaces. This decision comes through the case of City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, where the court reversed a previous decision that was firmly rooted in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit.

The Origins of the Case

The challenges began in Grants Pass, Oregon, where local politicians attempted to quash the homeless population by enforcing steep fines and jail terms. This verdict will have a monumental impact on people with disabilities, as they are overwhelmingly more likely to experience homelessness. Figures reveal that nearly 78 percent of homeless people report having mental health conditions and a staggering 52 percent of homeless adults in shelters nationwide have a disability.

Impact on People With Disabilities

The lack of physically accessible and affordable housing for people who rely on Social Security Disability Insurance and Supplemental Security Income often pushes them into homelessness, with data showing that only 6 percent of homes are wheelchair-friendly nationwide. Indeed, this case highlighted the vulnerability of the disabled community, as many individuals who could not stay at the only Grants Pass shelter due to their disqualifying disabilities presented their plights.

Historical Perspective and Implications

The application of Robinson v. California, a Supreme Court ruling from 1962, was instrumental in the appellants’ argument. The Robinson ruling was historic in asserting that the Eighth Amendment precludes state and local governments from penalizing a status, such as drug addiction.

However, in an unsettling trend reversal, the Supreme Court’s majority judgement led by Justice Neil Gorsuch distanced Grants Pass v. Johnson from Robinson, stating that the Grants Pass statute only prohibits actions like sleeping outdoors and does not differentiate based on housing status. Despite numerous disability rights groups filing briefs urging the court to consider disability-related implications, the verdict remained noticeably silent on the subject.

A Counterpoint

Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s dissent blatantly highlights the disproportionate effect that these rulings would have on the disability community, and she quotes extensively from amicus briefs filed by groups fighting for disability rights. For her, the ordinances are a direct criminalization of being homeless, particularly concerning those who have no access to shelter.

In conclusion, even amidst significant rulings that would considerably impact the rights of disabled people, it becomes vital for the courts and public to understand what lies at stake. Disability rights groups vow to persevere in their opposition, ensuring that constitutional guarantees and federal disability rights protections truly stand up for those most in need.


Author: HERE Charleston

HERE Charleston

Recent Posts

Supreme Court to Hear Case on South Carolina’s Medicaid Funding Cuts to Planned Parenthood

Supreme Court to Review South Carolina's Medicaid Funding for Planned Parenthood Washington – The Supreme…

11 hours ago

Charleston Man Awarded $63 Million in Landmark Johnson & Johnson Talc Case

Charleston Man Awarded $63 Million in Landmark Johnson & Johnson Talc Case In a shocking…

13 hours ago

Appalachian State Aims to Overcome Road Struggles Against Dominant Charleston Cougars

Charleston, South Carolina – A Clash of College Basketball Teams In a thrilling college basketball…

14 hours ago

Conway’s Former Senate Candidate Ordered to Pay $76,000 in Frivolous Defamation Case

Conway's Former Senate Candidate Faces Legal Blow Over Defamation Lawsuit CONWAY — **John Gallman**, a…

14 hours ago

Cold Snap to Bring Sub-Zero Temperatures to Columbia This Weekend

Cold Snap Approaches Columbia, South Carolina Columbia, S.C. — The News19 Weather Team has issued…

14 hours ago